Wednesday, July 10, 2013

The Morning Call--the economy, si; valuations, no


The Morning Call

7/10/13

The Market
           
    Technical

            Yesterday was another good day for the indices (DJIA 15300, S&P 1652).  The pin action confirmed the break of the very short term downtrend off the May 22 highs.
That sets the short term trends as trading ranges (14190-15550, 1576-1687).  However, they remain solidly within their intermediate term (14295-19295, 1520-2108) and long term uptrends (4783-17500, 688-1750).

            Volume fell; breadth improved.  The VIX declined and is closing in on the very short term uptrend off its May 22 low.  It finished within its intermediate term downtrend.

            GLD climbed but it remains outside the boundaries of all major trends and its chart completely broken.

Bottom line:  the Averages look ready to attack their May 22 highs.  Technically speaking, I see no reason why that wouldn’t be successful.  Breadth is quite positive; our stocks are in the process of reversing to the upside. 

That said, short term the indices are still in a trading range and will be until those May 22 highs are surpassed.  Whether or not the break to the upside takes place means little to me with stocks are current valuations.  Indeed, any additional move to the upside that takes any of our stocks into their Sell Half Ranges will be a further opportunity to do just that.

            Update on ‘the best stock market indicator ever’:

    Fundamental

     Headlines

            In the US, the sole economic datapoint was weekly retail sales which were positive.  That was offset by reports of declining expectations for corporate revenues, White House lowering forecasts for 2013 GDP and the IMF reducing its global economic growth estimates---all of which are in direct contradiction to the growing Market consensus of an improving US economy. 

Clearly, no one gave a s**t.  Money continues to pour into the stock market and once again, any news is either good news or ignored.  How long this lasts is anyone’s guess.

***over night, Chinese exports fell dramatically; S&P lowered the credit rating of Italy.

Bottom line: I hate having to question valuations when I am sanguine on the economy.  However, as I have lamented often in these pages, our positive economic outlook when plugged into our Valuation Model simply can’t get valuations to current levels.  And it is our Valuation Model that determines the timing of any purchases and sales. 

In this latest uptrend, almost 25% of our stocks have traded into their Sell Half Ranges and have been reduced to 50% positions---that is where most of the cash on our sheets has come from. 

Clearly, it can be argued that our Model recommended selling too soon to which I respond, in general that is exactly right.  But to be clear, it is not a function of the Model’s Market Valuation.  Rather it is a by product of how our Valuation Model  establishes value for each stock; and for the last thirty years the natural result has been that many of our high quality stocks reach stretched valuations before the Market in general.  Hence, our Portfolios have always been early to Sell relative to the Market. 

Of course, I apply the same Valuation formula to the indices that I do to the individual stocks; BUT the indices being overvalued (as they are now) have never been a reason to Buy or Sell individual stocks.  It is always the individual valuations that drive transactions.  The one impact that Market overvaluation has is to slow the rate of any new Buys---but that has never altered our Portfolios’ cash position by more than 5-6%.

So as painful as it is to own more cash than I may want at this very moment, I continue to believe that long term our strategy will keep our Portfolio’s performance competitive through a Market cycle but with a lot less volatility.  Until that formula no longer works, I remain committed.  Our Portfolios will continue to take advantage of any upward price movement that drives any of our stocks into their Sell Half Ranges.
    
            The revenue recession (medium):

            The fog surrounding ‘too big to fail’ (medium):

            The Fed’s bind (medium):



Steve Cook received his education in investments from Harvard, where he earned an MBA, New York University, where he did post graduate work in economics and financial analysis and the CFA Institute, where he earned the Chartered Financial Analysts designation in 1973. His 40 years of investment experience includes institutional portfolio management at Scudder, Stevens and Clark and Bear Stearns. Steve's goal at

No comments:

Post a Comment