Thursday, March 21, 2019

The Morning Call--Why did the Market selloff on dovish Fed news?


The Morning Call

3/21/19
The Market
         
    Technical

The Averages (DJIA 25745, S&P 2824) had a roller coaster day, finishing down.  Still the S&P closed well above the 2800 as well as the 2811/2815 former resistance levels; so, technically, at this point, I see no reason to doubt further upside in prices.

Volume rose and breadth was mixed.

The VIX advanced 2 ½ %, finishing back above the late February/early March double bottom, negating last Friday’s break.  While this did represent follow through from Tuesday’s advance, I remain in doubt that there has been a directional change---just like the S&P.

The long bond spiked 1% on volume---largely due to the FOMC’s dovish statement (more below).  It blew through the quad top; if it remains there through the close next Monday, it will reestablish a very short term uptrend.  Clearly, the chart is on the verge of becoming much stronger.

***overnight,

The dollar declined ½ % on volume, closing below the upper boundary of the November to present trading range and right on its 100 DMA.  A break below that MA would signal a weakening in the technical underpinnings of UUP.

GLD was up 5/8 % on volume, finishing above both MA’s, above the most recent lower high (signifying a possible improvement in trend) and in a short term uptrend.  

Bottom line: the S&P ended above 2800/2811/2815; so, there remains little visible resistance between its current price and its all-time high.  However, while stocks initially rallied on the Fed news, they subsequently sold off---not only contrary to the thesis that a dovish Fed is good for stocks but also a bit out of line with TLT, GLD and UUP.  I end the day confused.

TLT, UUP and GLD acted exactly as I would have expected on a super dovish statement from the FOMC.  Clearly, these investors believe that an easier than anticipated Fed is good (TLT, GLD) or bad (UUP). 

            Wednesday in the charts.

    Fundamental

       Headlines

            Only one US stat reported yesterday: weekly mortgage and purchase applications were up.

            Overseas, the January Japanese leading economic index was in line; February UK inflation was in line, PPI was less than projected and industrial orders were disappointing.

            It was also another day in the topsy turvy world of trade negotiations---Trump says tariffs on Chinese goods could remain for a long time.

            All of this was dwarfed by the news following the FOMC meeting which basically moved stated Fed policy in line with the dovish, ‘patient’ narrative from various Fed members since January, to wit:

(1)   rates were left unchanged, are expected to remain so through the end of 2019 with only one rate increase expected in 2020 and one in 2021,

(2)   the balance sheet run off will begin to slow in May and will end in September,

(3)   its outlook for economic growth was lowered and unemployment was raised, i.e. the economy is not quite as rosy as previously portrayed.

In sum, the Fed out doved itself.  My question is, why?  The Market wasn’t expecting the extent of the move toward ease.  So, there was no reason to pacify it as there was in January.  On the other hand, given its downgrade in the economic outlook (however small it may have been), I wonder if it is finally starting to acknowledge that its forecast has been way too rosy.  Certainly, the dramatic flattening of the yield curve suggests that bond investors may think so (and you know that I have always had more respect for the bond market’s versus the stock market’s ability to discount future economic events).  However, a selloff in stock prices on fears of recession would fit that scenario.  Of course, we need more data and more than a one day move in bond/stock prices to give any credence to that notion.
      
            FOMC projections.

            Fed hubris.

            ***overnight, the Bank of England left rates unchanged and QT on hold.  The narrative in the subsequent statement focused heavily on Brexit---as you might expect.


            Bottom line: given equity investor’s persistent jigginess to a dovish Fed, it is somewhat mystifying to me that stocks would sell off on a more dovish that expected FOMC policy statement.  However, as in noted above, this is one day’s reaction which borders on being meaningless.  Follow through will tell the tale.

P.S.  I have long maintained that the Fed has never, ever in its history managed the successful transition from easy to normal monetary policy.  This analyst believes yesterday’s dovish move locks in that scenario again.


    News on Stocks in Our Portfolios
 
General Mills (NYSE:GIS): Q3 Non-GAAP EPS of $0.83 beats by $0.14; GAAP EPS of $0.74.
Revenue of $4.2B (+8.2% Y/Y) misses by $10M.

Economics

   This Week’s Data

      US

            Weekly jobless claims were 221,000 versus expectations of 225,000

            The March Philadelphia Fed manufacturing index came in at 13.7 versus estimates of 4.5.

     International

            February UK retail sales rose 0.4% versus projections of -0.4%; ex gasoline, they increased 0.2% versus consensus of -0.4%.

    Other

            Just stop spending.

            Whose fault is the Brexit mess?

            China’s Belt and Road Initiative.

            Chinese corporations defaulting on loans at a record level.

What I am reading today

            How archeologists found Troy.

                Quote of the day.

                Bonus quote of the day.


                The state is not a transcendental being.




Visit Investing for Survival’s website (http://investingforsurvival.com/home) to learn more about our Investment Strategy, Prices Disciplines and Subscriber Service.




No comments:

Post a Comment