Tuesday, March 19, 2013

The Morning Call--the initial Cyprus plan speaks volumes

The Morning Call

3/19/13

The Market
           
    Technical

            The indices (DJIA 14452, S&P 1552) remain out of sync, with the Dow above its previous all time high (14190) and the upper boundary of its short term uptrend (13726-14391) and the S&P below those comparable levels (1576) and (1495-1569) respectively.  Both remain within their intermediate term uptrends (13517-18517, 1433-2017) and their long term uptrends (4783-17500, 688-1750).

            Volume fell; breadth deteriorated, with on balance volume looking ugly.  The VIX not unexpectedly jumped 13%, finishing within its short term and intermediate term downtrends.

            GLD had a good day, though it remains solidly within a short term downtrend. 

Bottom line: while the Averages were down on the day, I was surprised that the decline wasn’t worse given the headlines out of Cyprus.  That suggests one of two things to me---either the bulls remain alive and well and continue to ignore bad news or I am unrealistically pessimistic about the downside risk of the EU sovereign/bank solvency problems. 

We will know more in a couple of weeks.  In the meantime, I am sticking with the former interpretation with the caveat that I am open to changing my mind.  The question remains, is this a topping process or a pause before another leg up? 

However, even if there is a break to the upside, I don’t believe that a next leg will cover much distance as the indices will be bumping up against the upper boundaries of an 80 year uptrend. 

As a result, our Portfolios remain better sellers.

            Options point to a big move (medium):

    Fundamental
    
     Headlines

            No economic news yesterday; and if there had been, it probably wouldn’t have mattered anyway.  Unless you were in a vacuum chamber, you know investor attention was focused on the terms of the Cyprus banks bail out which were announced over the weekend.  I provided the terms in yesterday’s Morning Call to which I add the following three links addressing the key issues:

            JP Morgan on Cyprus (medium):

            Cyprus, the next blunder (medium):

            Counterpoint (medium):

            Part of the bail out includes the provision that Cyprus must supply one half of the bail out funds (roughly $5.8 billion).  What has tightened the most sphincters is (1) the tax [confiscation?] of a portion of depositors’ capital even those for whom deposit insurance would apply and (2) the absence of any contribution to the bank bail out from senior lenders.  In other words, the banksters skate and the little guys take it in the snoot.

            At 8AM EST the Universe was in agreement that this was one of the stupidest moves the eurocrats could have made.  And at the moment of this writing, there are rumors everywhere that the deposit insurance will be reinstated and that senior lenders will be forced to take part of the $5.8 billion hit.

            Here is an entertaining response from an average European on just how moronic the Cyprus bail out (in) is (9 minute video):

            Ashes to reality (medium):

            Giving them at least some credit for reversing a foolish plan, we are still left with several questions:

(1) how could they have been that stupid in the first place?  Doesn’t it reflect beyond a reasonable doubt just how little these guys understand about the problems that they are being paid to solve? What is to prevent them from making an equally idiotic decision in the future but where a much larger sovereign/bank is involved and there is little time to reverse their actions before real damage is done? 

(2) how much damage has already been done to depositor psychology?  Will this move build in a guaranteed bank run during the next hiccup?

(3) many of the large depositors in Cypriot banks are Russian government officials, oligarchs and mafia.  They are still going to take a hit and it may be higher that originally reported as they may have to share with the senior debt holders the deficit created by re-guaranteeing the deposit insurance.  How is that going to work out?  History tells us that ‘you don’t fool with Mother Russia’. So if I were a Cypriot banker I would be trying to cut in line for the FBI’s new identity and relocation program.  Or maybe the Russians demand reparations.  At the moment speculation is that Gazprom has ‘volunteered’ to supply the necessary funds in exchange for the drilling rights to Cyprus’ offshore acreage---said to be quite large.

The bad news here is that (1) this is just one more example of poor bank regulation and incompetent eurocrat leadership that could easily create an even larger disaster and (2) the uncertainty this creates about depositor psychology in other EU countries.

The good news is that (1) Cyprus is a wart on a goat’s ass and, therefore, its banking problems shouldn’t be sufficient to bring down the EU much less the global financial system [barring more numbskull eurocrat solutions] and (2) the US will probably benefit as it appears once again to be the best house in a rotten neighborhood.

Bottom line:  while it seems that the Cyprus situation may turn out to be less severe than thought at the outset, I do think that we need to let it play out a bit longer before breathing a sigh of relief.  Furthermore, even if the US is the best horse in a herd of nags, the issue remains, what do you pay for that? 

Our Valuation Model suggests that the current investor risk/reward equation is not attractive enough, except on a very speculative, short term trading basis, to warrant chasing prices up from here.

            I like our cash position.

            More on valuation (short/medium):




Steve Cook received his education in investments from Harvard, where he earned an MBA, New York University, where he did post graduate work in economics and financial analysis and the CFA Institute, where he earned the Chartered Financial Analysts designation in 1973. His 40 years of investment experience includes institutional portfolio management at Scudder, Stevens and Clark and Bear Stearns. Steve's goal at Strategic Stock Investments is to help other investors build wealth and benefit from the investing lessons he learned the hard way.

No comments:

Post a Comment