Thursday, December 6, 2012

The Morning Call--It is all just Kabuki theater

-->
The Morning Call

12/6/12

The Market
           
    Technical

            The indices (DJIA 13034, S&P 1409) managed to close slightly higher on a volatile day with massive internal divergences (some stocks up big [Traveler]; some stocks down big [Apple]), but remained within (1) their short term trading ranges [12460-13302, 1343-1422] and (2) their intermediate term uptrends [12880-17880, 1361-1956].

            Volume rose; breadth improved further.  The VIX fell, closing right on its 50 day moving average (a move lower would be a plus for stocks) and remains in the ever narrowing zone between the upper boundary of its short term downtrend and the lower boundary of its intermediate term trading range.

            GLD was off fractionally, finishing below its 50 day moving average but above the lower boundaries of its short term uptrend and its intermediate term trading range.  GLD continues its sickly performance.  As you know, our Portfolios Sold their trading positions in GLD in what proved to be a lousy trade; a move below the lower boundary of its short term uptrend (circa 161) will likely prompt some lightening in their investment positions.

            Bottom line: the S&P has been locked in a pretty tight range (1395-1422) for the last two weeks during which it could not make a higher high from early November---not a sign of strength.  My guess is that whatever the direction it is moving when it busts out of this trading range will likely follow though for the short term. 

In any case, with the S&P in the upper half of its short term trading range, there is nothing technically compelling about putting cash to work.

    Fundamental
    
     Headlines

            Yesterday’s economic data were upbeat: the ADP private payroll number was up, though less than expected; third quarter nonfarm productivity was better than estimates; October factory orders were much better than anticipated; and the November ISM nonmanufacturing index came in positive and above forecasts.  In sum, these stats support of current outlook.

            However, the Market most of the day focused on the fiscal cliff.  The first  headline was talk of some republicans breaking ranks and be willing to accept tax rate hikes.  That got stocks moving to the upside.  The surprising thing is that anyone would think that this is news.  It is clear to me that republicans are going to have to fold on the tax rate issue; it is the only way that they are going to get any spending cuts at all. 

            Boehner more or less emphasized that point when it was later reported that he was threatening those GOP members who were unwilling to go along with his fiscal cliff proposals with their House committee assignments (read status).  So it appears to me that Boehner knows the republicans have to give some on the point of tax rates and he starting to knock heads to get it done.

As you know, this outcome (higher tax rates) is not one that I want.  But Obama and dems are completely outclassing the GOP on the propaganda front; and I think Boehner sees the hand writing on the wall.  So unless republicans get a whole lot better at making their case, their choices, it seems to me, is to either get what they can get in the budget negotiations, proclaim a ‘just’ compromise and lick their wounds or push the economy over the cliff, take the blame for the subsequent recession and get clocked in 2014.  My bet is that a major of the GOP officeholders will conclude that discretion is the better part of valor and fold.

I may not like the resulting agreement which will undoubtedly include some unattractive combination of higher taxes and few real spending cuts; but that is the outcome I have figured into our Economic Model---so it will be no surprise.  The good news is that stocks are presently Fairly Valued on that assumption. 

            P.S. after the Market close, in an interview on CNBC, Geithner stated unequivocally that the administration is prepared to go over the cliff, if doesn’t get tax rate increases.  That may have an impact on early trading this morning.  My take is that this is just part of the Kabuki dance going on in DC and does little to alter my opinion of the ultimate outcome.

            P.P.S. overnight in Europe, third quarter eurozone GDP was down, Greek unemployment was up, German factory orders were up, the ECB left interest rates unchanged and S&P downgraded Greek debt to ‘selective default’.

Bottom line: there is clearly more to come on the fiscal cliff as well as the EU sovereign/bank debt crisis.   For the moment the fiscal cliff is the focus of investor attention; however as you know, I think that:

(1) it will ultimately have less to do with our economic outlook than the EU problem because the likely non-optimal solution is already priced into our Model,

(2) though on a short term basis, it could still roil the Markets.  Because if history repeats itself, our political class will only come to an agreement at the last possible minute---which will scare the be-jesus out of investors.  Indeed, it may take a Market panic to force that last minute compromise.
 
The good news is that a panic could provide a buying opportunity if it pushes prices sufficiently low to also incorporate the real risk to our forecast, i.e. a debacle in Europe.

The latest from David Rosenberg (medium):

      Subscriber Alert
           
            The stock price of CR Bard (BCR-$97) traded below the upper boundary of its Buy Value Range.  Accordingly, it is being Added to the Dividend Growth Buy List.  The Dividend Growth Portfolio already owns a full position in BCR, so no action will be taken.

            The stock price of Atrion (ATRI-$197) traded below the upper boundary of its Buy Value Range.  Therefore, it is being Added to the Aggressive Growth Buy List.  The Aggressive Growth Portfolio owns no shares in ATRI; but no shares will be Bought at this time.



Steve Cook received his education in investments from Harvard, where he earned an MBA, New York University, where he did post graduate work in economics and financial analysis and the CFA Institute, where he earned the Chartered Financial Analysts designation in 1973. His 40 years of investment experience includes institutional portfolio management at Scudder, Stevens and Clark and Bear Stearns. Steve's goal at Strategic Stock Investments is to help other investors build wealth and benefit from the investing lessons he learned the hard way.

No comments:

Post a Comment