Tuesday, November 19, 2013

The Morning Call--Icahn is a party pooper

The Morning Call

11/19/13

The Market
           
    Technical
           
            The indices (DJIA 15976, S&P 1791) turned in a very disjointed performance yesterday.  Both blew through the round number levels---16000/1800---then retreated; the Dow closing up while the S&P was down.  Nevertheless, both remained within uptrends across all time frames: short term (15299-20299, 1717-1871), intermediate term (15299-20299, 1633-2215) and long term (5015-17000, 728-1850). 

However, the pin action was the second S&P ‘outside’ down day in as many weeks.  As you know, the first one had zero relevance; so this time may simply be a repeat.   On the other hand, these ‘outside’ days are infrequent enough and historically have signaled reversals often enough, that we should pay attention.  So be a bit cautions over the next couple of days in whatever you may be doing in the Market.

            Volume fell; breadth was mixed.  The VIX popped 7%, bouncing off the lower boundary of its short term trading range.  It also finished within an intermediate term downtrend.

For the bulls’ (short):

            The long Treasury rose in price, but remains in a short term trading range.  It is also in an intermediate term downtrend.

            GLD fell, closing noticeably below the point of the pennant formation I discussed on Monday---which suggests a trend to lower prices.

Bottom line:  the Averages made new all time highs intraday, hitting the magic round numbers of Dow 16000 and S&P 1800 before falling back by the closing bell.  I don’t think that there is anything necessarily ominous about that pin action.

However, the above link of the positive advance/decline stats notwithstanding there remain numerous signs that breadth is deteriorating, including our own internal indicator.  That suggests to me that this is a time to do nothing, even on a trading basis.

Foreign purchases of US stocks hits low (medium):

Indeed as a longer term investor, I would take advantage of the current high prices to sell any stock that has been a disappointment and to trim the holding of any stock that has doubled or more in price.

If one of our stocks trades into its Sell Half Range, our Portfolios will act accordingly.
           
    Fundamental
    
     Headlines

            There was almost no economic news flow yesterday either here or abroad.  So in a complacent world where investors tend to interpret any news as good news, then no news must almost certainly be good news.  As a result, stocks ramped at the open, shooting above the magical ‘round numbers’ of 16000/1800 and then traded around that level for most of the day.

            ***over night (1) in China, interest rates continued to rise; the central bank announced that it will exit currency intervention and remove the ceiling on bank deposit rates and (2) the OECD lowered is estimated global economic growth rate.

            Then late in the trading day, Carl Icahn was speaking at an investor conference and suggested that stocks might be a bit expensive and that he was concerned.  That sent stocks lower.  Personally, Icahn does not rate at the top of my list of acute Market strategists.  Indeed, my guess is that he wouldn’t rate himself as a Market strategist.  On the other hand, given his past tactics, I am cynical enough to think that there might be a motive for making bearish noises other than just expressing an honest opinion.  Whatever his motive, this will likely have little impact today---barring it developing into one of those ‘emperor’s new clothes’ moments.

            Icahn’s comments (short):

Bottom line: the assumptions in our Economic and Valuation Models remain on track, including those of an over easy Fed that bungles the transition from easy to tight money and a half assed solution to our fiscal problems.  Of particular concern to me is the former which I worry will end far worse than is reflected in our Model.

I remain confident in the Fair Values generated by our Valuation Model; hence, stocks are overvalued.  Of course, there is some likelihood that they can get even more overvalued if the large number of underperforming money managers choose to chase potential higher returns through year end. 

This doesn’t mean that stocks are a value; it means that catching up is an economic necessity for those trailing money managers.  It may also mean that by the end of December, a Chevy Market could be carrying not a Cadillac, but a Mercedes price.

            The latest from John Hussman (medium):

            The latest from Jeremy Grantham (medium):

            More on valuation (medium):

            And

            And this wrap up on the recently completed earnings season (short):




Steve Cook received his education in investments from Harvard, where he earned an MBA, New York University, where he did post graduate work in economics and financial analysis and the CFA Institute, where he earned the Chartered Financial Analysts designation in 1973. His 40 years of investment experience includes institutional portfolio management at Scudder, Stevens and Clark and Bear Stearns. Steve's goal at Investing For Survival is to help other investors build wealth and benefit from the investing lessons he learned the hard way.

No comments:

Post a Comment