Friday, December 21, 2012

The Morning Call--Oops

-->
The Morning Call

12/21/12

The Market
           
    Technical

            The indices (DJIA 13311, S&P 1433) resumed their uptrend.  The S&P remains in its newly re-set short term uptrend (1423-1475), while the DJIA traded back above the upper boundary of its short term trading range.  This will re-start the time element of our time and distance discipline for the confirmation of break out of its short term trading range.  In the meantime (three more trading days), the Averages will be out of sync.  Both are well within their intermediate term uptrends (12997-17997, 1372-1967).

            Volume decline; breadth improved.  The VIX was actually up (typically it is down on an up Market day).  It is above its 50 day moving average and within shouting distance of the upper boundary of its short term downtrend.  A break above this trend line would be a negative for stocks.  This unusual pin action on the VIX suggests that there could be some serious hedging going on.

            GLD (160) got whacked again.  As a result, the break of the lower boundary of its short term uptrend is confirmed.  With much of drop early in day, our Portfolios sold half of their investment position in GLD---that leaves them with roughly a 5% holding in GLD.

            I know, I know.  If our economic forecast is correct, then history says GLD is going higher.  So why are our Portfolios Selling?  The immediate answer is that I could be wrong; and, as you know, one of my most important investment principles is to never take a loss because the pin action doesn’t agree with my outlook.

            To be sure, there could be a number of reasons why the GLD price is declining even though long term the forces are in place to move it higher, e.g. gold is not a deep liquid market; so if a large fund is in forced liquidation, the volatility to the downside will be big (it is rumored that John Paulson’s hedge fund---a big GLD holder---is getting redemption notices and the rest of the hedgies are front running his sales).

            There could also be more fundamental reasons: (1) it was rumored that China cancelled a major soybean purchase---suggesting that its economy, and by extension the global economy, is weaker than currently believed.  (2)  on the other hand, it appears that investors around the world are selling most non stock asset classes and are rushing into stocks.   

Clearly, if this crowd is correct, then I will have been wrong owning too much GLD.  I don’t think that this is necessarily the case but it is certainly a challenge to our current investment strategy and it tells me that I need to redouble my normal effort to test the assumptions in our Models.  Until that examination is over, the most practical, least risky steps that I can take is to Sell GLD to stop the erosion of profits in this holding. 

If this latest collapse in the price of gold turns out to be some sort of trading/liquidity anomaly, then I may be getting ‘whip sawed’.  However,  I am willing to accept the cost of trading out and then back into a position to insure that our Portfolios preserve a profit.

            Meanwhile, some reading from those who agree with me about the long term outlook for GLD (all are short):

            And (short):

            And (short):

Bottom line: the Holiday party resumed yesterday.  While I don’t believe it, our thesis on gold is being challenged.  So I have some work ahead of me.  In the meantime, loss avoidance is the first order of business; hence our Portfolios sale of one half of their GLD investment position.

I note that there are now 18 stocks out of our 157 stock Universe that are on the cusp of challenging the upper boundary of multi year trading ranges.  Whether or not they break through these barriers should tell me a lot about Market direction.

            Bullish sentiment near highs (short):
           
Most bear markets start near year end (short):

            And this from Chris Kimble (short):

    Fundamental
    
     Headlines

            Lots of economic data to digest yesterday: weekly jobless claims rose (negative), third quarter GDP was revised up but that was a function of inventory building (mixed at best), the leading economic indicators were down but that was expected (neutral), existing homes sales and the Philly Fed manufacturing index were both much better than forecasts.  Soooo.............a mixed to positive day; though following a couple days of disappointing stats, I have to rate it a plus for the simple reason that this pattern fits our Model.

            The rest of the day---well, you know.  More drama on the fiscal cliff.  It was anticipated that the House would vote on Boehner’s Plan B last night.  Pelosi, Reid and Obama spent the day pronouncing it DOA.  Then the unthinkable happened---Boehner couldn’t get enough GOP votes to get passed.  Now all bets are off.

Bottom line: I spent yesterday contemplating whether I am just not getting with the program or are my fellow stock jocks are drinking too much egg nog.  In the midst of that process, Plan B blew up and I was rescued.

Now the issue is, has the market-crash-forcing-the-politicians-to-reach-a-compromise scenario suddenly become operative.

While we await the answer, our outlook remains: (1) we get a compromise on the fiscal cliff which will solve nothing, (2) the Fed keeps inching further out of a limb, printing dollars at hyper speed and (3) the EU’s survival is balanced on the edge of a knife and if it falls, look out below. 

            So far, the primary (Treasury) dealers are not betting on higher rates (short):



Steve Cook received his education in investments from Harvard, where he earned an MBA, New York University, where he did post graduate work in economics and financial analysis and the CFA Institute, where he earned the Chartered Financial Analysts designation in 1973. His 40 years of investment experience includes institutional portfolio management at Scudder, Stevens and Clark and Bear Stearns. Steve's goal at Strategic Stock Investments is to help other investors build wealth and benefit from the investing lessons he learned the hard way.

No comments:

Post a Comment