Friday, October 5, 2012

The Morning Call--I hope the debate was a game changer but........


The Market
           
    Technical

            The indices (DJIA 13575, S&P 1461) had another decent day yesterday, closing well within their primary trends (1) short term uptrends [13268-14038, 1423-1513] and (2) intermediate term uptrends [12484-17464, 1316-1916].  Additional major resistance exists at 14190/1576 and support at 13302/1422.  Minor resistance has developed in the 13653/1469 area.

            Volume was flat; breadth (advance/decline, flow of funds, up/down volume) improved.  The VIX fell but still finished within the zone between the upper boundary of its short term downtrend and the lower boundary of its intermediate term trading range.

            GLD (173.6) jumped, closing near the upper boundary of its intermediate term trading range (175.2).  This resistance level has been tested twice before and held; so it clearly brings out the sellers.  If GLD were to break this level, the August 2011 highs (circa 186) mark the next area of resistance.

            Bottom line: the primary price trends continue to the upside as investor psychology remains ebullient.  Good news and bad news alike are interpreted as good news; and the ‘tail risks’ associated with the ‘fiscal cliff’, an EU crisis, accelerating inflation and war in the Middle East are being largely ignored.

Investors have certainly been right thus far to make those kind of interpretations. However, given the extent that the internal market structure is weaker (in my analysis) than is obvious in the price of the indices and my unwillingness to discount the odds or magnitude of the aforementioned ‘tail risks’, our Portfolios are carrying higher than normal level of cash and my focus is on our Sell versus our Buy Discipline.

            Bullish sentiment drops (short):

    Fundamental
    
     Headlines

            Yesterday’s economic news was tilted to the negative side: weekly jobless claims were over expectations and August factory orders were pretty rotten.  On the other hand, September chain store sales were acceptable though not great.

            However, once again early news out of Europe got all the headlines.  In yesterday’s case, Draghi was out making grandiose statements again---this time, he pronounced that the EU crisis countries were making progress (he clearly didn’t check with Greek longshoremen who stormed government offices) and that he was ready to start bailing out, so come on down.  That caused stocks to surge initially and they held the morning levels throughout the remainder of the day.

            Some pundits opined that Romney’s debate performance was a contributing factor to the early morning up tick presumably on the assumptions that:

(1)                            the odds of a GOP November victory had improved.   I am not going to agree or disagree with this notion.  Clearly, yesterday’s intrade pin action [odds of an Obama victory declined] supports this point.  And to be sure, I hope this interpretation is correct.

That said, there is still plenty of time and two more debates before the election for the Romney to screw up; and that assumes that he doesn’t slide back into his Casper Milquetoast persona as he did after the Ryan nomination.  So to me, buying stocks based on one good debate performance may be a bit premature.

(2)                            and the GOP is more likely to cure our fiscal ills than the dems. I will agree with this notion but with prejudice.  Talk is cheap and the last time the republicans controlled the purse strings, their record was an abomination.  I haven’t run a check on how many republicans who were in congress then that will also be there in January 2013; but I have an uneasy feeling that answer is ‘a lot’.  If that same worthless crew remains in place, I am hesitant to get jiggy about a sudden reversal fiscal, monetary and regulatory policies.

To be clear, I hope Romney wins; I hope the GOP has been reborn; I hope they win the presidency and the majority in both chambers---and if all of that all comes true, then it would remove my concerns that the US economy will not return to its higher historical secular growth rate.  But right now, in my opinion, actions trump words; and until we start seeing the right action, color me skeptical. 

            Later on, the Fed released the minutes from its last FOMC meeting.  As usual, we didn’t learn much from the document; although I was a bit surprised that there wasn’t more disagreement over the new ‘all in’ policy.  Those minutes are linked below for those of you into early morning self torture.

            The problem with QEIII (medium):

            Bottom line: as I said in yesterday’s Morning Call, I would love to believe that Romney will win and that he will bring change to DC.  But with so much for him and the  rest of the GOP yet to prove and with stocks already overvalued, I have a tough time making a bet on that outcome.  Doesn’t mean I don’t want it; doesn’t mean it wouldn’t lift the P/E on stocks if it happened.  It does mean that I am not going to risk my money on it until I see at the least the reasonable prospect of the needed results.

In the meantime, Draghi is no closer to solving the EU sovereign/bank debt problems, Greece is on the verge of bankruptcy and Spain is a close second.  Again, I hope that the eurocrats can fashion some creditable policies to effectively deal with the issues.  Indeed, that is our forecast.  But I am increasingly dismayed at the ineptitude of the EU political class and as a result, have to leave the odds of a ‘tail risk’ event at somewhere between 30% and 50%.  As a said above, with stocks overvalued, why do I want to be increasing our Portfolios’ equity exposure in this environment?

            Equities as an inflation hedge (short):

No comments:

Post a Comment